Posts Tagged ‘maps’

The Ukraine War Map Problem

Saturday, September 3rd, 2022

When the Russo-Ukrainian war kicked off back in February, I relied on https://liveuamap.com/ to track military action in the war, just as I had used their similar map when tracking the war against the Islamic State. However, after the initial phase of the war, LiveUAMap seemed to update less and less frequently, and it’s been practically useless for tracking progress in the Kherson counteroffensive.

Today, most video commentators on the war seem to rely on https://deepstatemap.live. Here’s today’s snapshot from Kherson:

Better than nothing, but not as good as LiveUAMap used to be.

Here YouTuber Suchomimus compares different maps of the Kherson offensive, and how the differ on territory captured.

He mentions the War_Mapper Twitter account, which I haven’t been following due to my ongoing Twitter timeout.

He also mentions the official Russian-sourced map, which I’m not particularly interested in trusting.

The Institute for the Study of War includes a map with their daily assessment updates, but they’re not interactive or particularly detailed.

There are also a few YouTubers who do daily map updates. There’s Denys Davydov (“Hello, my friends…”). He’s Ukrainian and upfront about his bias, and covers the various clashes across the entire front (which makes his videos a bit long, and I tend to skip around for the bits I’m interested in). He suffers from “The map is the territory” syndrome, and isn’t a deep tactical thinker or versed in the intricacies of combined arms operations, but he’s useful if you understand his limitations.

One of the maps he relies on (in addition to DeepState) is the MilitaryLand map, which looks really useful.

Ukraine News TV relies on the DeepState map, and goes into considerable detail recount the day’s events.

War in Ukraine isn’t great in terms of voiceover, but seem to have a lot of unit-specific information on his maps.

For the sake of completeness, I note WeebUnion, who says he’s objective but seems pro-Russian (and his commenters even more so). He’s not a dynamic voiceover talent, and he begins this video with “Hello, comrades,” so…yeah, I don’t follow him.

This is the map he’s using.

This is a quick rundown of the map resources I’ve run across. If you know of other useful source, feel free to share them in the comments below.