That the entire Russiagate storyline itself was a fraud and a farce is conclusively demonstrated by one decisive fact that can never be memory-holed: namely, the impetus for the scandal and subsequent investigation was the conspiracy theory that the Trump campaign had secretly and criminally conspired with the Russian government to interfere in the 2016 election, primarily hacking into the email inboxes of the DNC and Clinton campaign chief John Podesta. And a grand total of zero Americans were accused (let alone convicted) of participating in that animating conspiracy.
The New York Timesâ May, 2017 announcement of Robert Mueller as special counsel stated explicitly that his task was âto oversee the investigation into ties between President Trumpâs campaign and Russian officialsâ and specifically âinvestigate âany links and/or coordination between the Russian government and individuals associated with the campaign of President Donald Trump.ââ
The related secondary media-created conspiracy theory was that the Kremlin clandestinely controlled U.S. political institutions by virtue of sexual and financial blackmail held over President Trump, which they used to compel him to obediently obey their dictates. âI donât know what the Russians have on the president, politically, personally, or financiallyâ was the dark innuendo which House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and her media allies most loved to spout. âPrestige newsâ outlets created their own Q-Anon-level series of art designed to implant in Americansâ minds a slew of McCarthyite imagery showing the Kremlin (or an iconic Moscow cathedral they mistook for the Kremlin) having fully infiltrated Washingtonâs key institutions.
But that all came crashing down on their heads in April, 2019, when Mueller announced that he was closing his investigation without charging even a single American with the criminal conspiracy that launched the entire spectacle: criminally conspiring with the Russian government to interfere in the election. Again: while Mueller â like so many Washington special counsels before him â ended up snaring some operatives in alleged process crimes committed after the investigation commenced (lying to the FBI and obstruction of justice) or unrelated crimes (Manafortâs financial sleaze), the 18-month aggressive, sprawling investigation resulted in exactly zero criminal charges on the core claim that Trump officials had criminally conspired with Russia.
If that were not sufficient to make every person who drowned the country in this crazed conspiracy theory feel enormous shame (and it should have been), the former FBI Directorâs final Report explicitly stated that âthe investigation did not establish that members of the Trump campaign conspired or coordinated with the Russian government in its election.â In many cases, the Report went even further than this âdid not establishâ formulation to state that there was no evidence of any kind found for many of the key media conspiracies (âThe investigation did not identify evidence that any U.S. persons knowingly or intentionally coordinated with the IRAâs interference operationâ; the âevidence does not establish that one campaign officialâs efforts to dilute a portion of the Republican platform was undertaken at the behest of candidate Trump or Russiaâ; âthe investigation did not establish that [Carter] Page coordinated with the Russian government in its efforts to interfere in the 2016 presidential electionâ). The Report also barely even dignified let alone confirmed the long-standing, utterly deranged Democratic/media conspiracy theory that the Kremlin had taken over U.S. policy through blackmail.
For a few weeks following the issuance of the Mueller report, Democrats and media figures gamely attempted to deny that it obliterated the conspiracy theories to which they had relentlessly subjected the country for the prior four years. How could they do otherwise? They staked their entire reputations and the trust of their audience on having this be true. To avoid their day of reckoning, they would hype ancillary events such as Paul Manafortâs conviction on unrelated financial crimes or Michael Flynnâs guilty plea for a minor and dubious charge (for which even Mueller recommended no prison time) or Roger Stoneâs various process charges to insist that there was still a grain of truth to their multifaceted geopolitical fairy tale seemingly lifted straight from a Tom Clancy Cold War thriller about the worldâs two largest nuclear powers.
But even they knew this was just a temporary survival strategy and that it was unsustainable for the long term. That the crux of the scandal all along was that key Trump allies if not the President himself would be indicted and imprisoned for having conspired with the Russians was too glaring to make people forget about it.
That was why former CIA Director John Brennan assured the MSNBC audience in March â just weeks before Mueller closed his investigation with no conspiracy crimes alleged â that it was impossible that the investigation could close without first indicting Trumpâs children and other key White House aides on what Brennan correctly said was the whole point of the scandal from the start: âcriminal conspiracy involving the Russians . . . . whether or not U.S. persons were actively collaborating, colluding, cooperating, involved in a conspiracy with them or not.â Brennan strongly insinuated that among those likely to be indicted for criminally conspiring with the Russians were those âfrom the Trump family.â
As we all know, literally none of that happened. Not only were Trump family members not indicted by Mueller on charges of âcriminal conspiracy involving the Russians,â no Americans were. Brennan believed there was no way that the Mueller investigation could end without that happening because that was the whole point of the scandal from the start. To explain why it had not happened up to that point after eighteen months of investigation by Muellerâs subpoena-armed and very zealous team of prosecutors, Brennan invented a theory that they were waiting to do that as the final act because they knew they would be fired by Trump once it happened. But it never happened because Mueller found no evidence to prove that it did.
In other words, the conspiracy theory that the media pushed on Americans since before Trumpâs inauguration â to the point where it drowned out most of U.S. politics and policy for years â proved to have no evidentiary foundation. And that is one reason I say that the sectors of the media pretending to be most distraught at the spread of âdisinformationâ by anonymous citizens on Facebook and 4Chan are, in fact, the most aggressive, prolific and destructive disseminators of that disinformation by far (nor was it uncredentialed YouTube hosts, Patreon podcasters or Substack writers who convinced Americans to believe that Saddam Hussein possessed nuclear weapons and was in an alliance with Al Qaeda but rather the editor-heavy prestige outlets such as The New York Times, The New Yorker, NBC News and The Atlantic).