The World Science Fiction Convention, the same people who thought it was a dandy idea to have a Worldcon in communist China, have stepped in it again. This time, the scandal is using ChatGPT to hunt wrongthink.
We have received questions regarding Seattle’s use of AI tools in our vetting process for program participants. In the interest of transparency, we will explain the process of how we are using a Large Language Model (LLM). We understand that members of our community have very reasonable concerns and strong opinions about using LLMs. Please be assured that no data other than a proposed panelist’s name has been put into the LLM script that was used. Let’s repeat that point: no data other than a proposed panelist’s name has been put into the LLM script. The sole purpose of using the LLM was to streamline the online search process used for program participant vetting, and rather than being accepted uncritically, the outputs were carefully analyzed by multiple members of our team for accuracy.
We received more than 1,300 panelist applicants for Seattle Worldcon 2025. Building on the work of previous Worldcons, we chose to vet program participants before inviting them to be on our program.
And by “vetting” program participants, they mean “barring anyone that doesn’t toe the far left social justice warrior line”:
Several individuals have asked to see the ChatGPT query that was used in the vetting process. In the interest of transparency, this was our prompt:
REQUEST
Using the list of names provided, please evaluate each person for scandals. Scandals include but are not limited to homophobia, transphobia, racism, harassment, sexual misconduct, sexism, fraud.
So all the usual social justice shibboleths. By “transphobia,” they mean to exclude anyone who believes in the reality of biological sex. Presumably if J. K. Rowling deemed to actually notice their existence, buy a membership, and asked to be on a panel, they would exclude the world’s most popular fantasy writer for her high crimes against social justice.
As for “racism,” remember that this is the con that lost a lawsuit to writer Jon Del Arroz for calling him a racist.
As for “homophobia,” remember that these are the same people who attacked Orson Scott Card for answering (correctly) that the Mormon church considers homosexuality a sin.
Worldcon and organized fandom is another institution the social justice warriors have killed in order to wear its skin as a trophy. Now they want to exclude from fandom anyone not infected with the far left woke mind virus.
The scandal isn’t that they outsourced their anti-wrongthink witchhunt to ChatGPT, the scandal is their need exclude differing opinions from what was formerly a robust, free-thinking community.
